Friday, November 20, 2026

All Experts Redux: Using The Stellar Magnitude Scale To Work Out Astronomy Problems

 Question:  I am interested in the stellar magnitude scale and using it to work out astronomy problems. Can you help?


Fig. 1: Stellar magnitude scale

Answer:

See Fig. 1 above for a stellar magnitude scale with the Sun at the extreme left or brightest end, with an apparent magnitude of (-27).


    The basic gist of the scale is that every 5 increments (UNITS) in magnitude difference translates into 100 times difference in brightness, because each succeeding magnitude is different from the earlier one by 2.512 times, since:(2.515)5 = 100. Thus a star of +1 magnitude is 100 times brighter than a star of +6 magnitude on the scale, since (6 – 1)= 5.

  So the layout of the scale is arithmetical, very much like the algebraic number line, but when related to brightness one obtains ratios not differences. And these ratios are based on a logarithmic relation. For example, the apparent magnitude of the Sun makes it apparently the brightest object in the sky. But this is only because it is at 1 A.U. distance. IF “moved” to 32.6 light years (the standard candle distance to obtain absolute magnitude) then one obtains +4.8 magnitude.

One can then inquire how distant the Sun would need to be to have that dimmer +4.8 magnitude.

Solution

    First obtain the difference in magnitudes using the scale (arithmetic difference):

(+4.8 - (-27) = 31.8 units of magnitude.

Then the brightness ratio is:

(2.5)31.8 = 4.5 x 1012

But the distance is related as the inverse square, so:

(d/d') = 1/(4.5 x 1012)1/2= 2.12 x 106

    So the Sun would have to be 
» 2.1 million times farther away 

or 3.1 x 10 14 AU .   Thus, its real magnitude in terms of the absolute standard (absolute magnitude) makes it somewhat dim.

Here, let's do a diversion to address the inverse square property of the brightness of light.

I will use the simple, everyday example of comparing two light bulbs. Thus, if I have a 100 watt bulb and place it at 1 m distance, then what would its relative brightness be when placed twice as far away or 2m? 

By the inverse square law for light, the intensity of a light source decreases as the inverse square of its distance, i,e,:

(d1/d2)2 = B2/ B1

      Where in this case, d1 = 1 m, B1 = 100 w and d2 = 2 d1 = 2m. Then, one needs to find the new brightness B2.

B2 = B1 (d1/d2)2

But (d1/d2)2  = (1/2)2 = ¼

Therefore: B2 = 100 w (¼) = 25 watts

Another Problem:

Beta Crucis has an apparent magnitude of +0.8 from 261 light years. Find its absolute magnitude.

Solution: The basis for the absolute magnitude as that apparent magnitude is always defined at a distance of 10 parsecs.  If there are 3.26 light years per parsec this means, 10 pc (3.26 ly/pc) = 32.6 light years. Then, for Beta Crucis:

(d1/d2) = 261 ly/ 32.6 ly = 8

Then:

(d1/d2)2  = (1/8)2 = 1/64

So:

B2/ B1 = 1/64

     In this case the object is being brought closer, so we want to find B1! Thus, B1= 64 B2. In other words, the star’s brightness at 32.6 light years is roughly 64 times more than its brightness at 261 light years which converts to a magnitude difference of: 4.5. 
So the new magnitude would be: (0.8 – 4.5) = -3.7.

That is, we locate +0.8 on the magnitude scale, then march off 4.5 units on it in direction of increased brightness.

Here's an additional problem for you to test your understanding of the inverse square law principle:

Two stars in the same constellation are named Alpha and Gamma. Both have the same absolute magnitude. Alpha is at a distance of 32.6 light years and has an apparent magnitude of +0.8. Gamma is at a distance of 261 light years.

Using the inverse square law of light, estimate how many times Gamma is dimmer than Alpha.


No comments: