Thursday, November 19, 2026

An In Depth Treatment of the Landou Contour - And Derivation Of Plasma Dispersion Function (Conclusion)

 

                               Deformed Landau contour

We left off in Part 2 denoting the frequency at  point A by
wA  - with the pole contributing a term to E(t) with time dependence, exp (-iwA t).  Such contributions are called normal modes since the frequencies are given by: 

e(k, w)   = 0, 

corresponding to the waves found by solving the dispersion equation:

1 + we2/ k2   ò  du  d u g(u)/ w/ k - u =0   

Now, after some time we expect the dominant contribution from these normal modes to come from the one with the biggest imaginary part of the frequency, such as in point A in the top graphic. If this is positive we say the normal mode is unstable given it grows with time. If negative, the normal mode is damped and decays with time.

Typically,  as we saw in Pt. 2, one looks at the dielectric function, i.e.  
 e(k, w)   = 1 -  we2/ k2   ò  du  d u g(u)/  u   - ( wp/ k) 

to see if any damping is associated with the normal modes.

Moving on, contributions must also be considered from segments in the contour like from point B to point C.  Then let the contour be a distance:

 d > 0  below the real w-axis, then the contribution has the form:

E(t) ~  ò C B      dw/ 2p  wi exp (-iw t) = 

exp (-g t)  ò C B      dw/ 2p  E(w) exp (-iwr t)

Decaying very rapidly with time (note the exp(-t) factor).  This means after an initial transience such contributions can be ignored.  Another set of contributions is derived from the point E, of the form:

E(t) ~  ò ED      dw/ 2p  E(w) exp (-iw t) 

=    exp (-iwo t) ò ED      dw/ 2p  E(wo + iwi) exp (wi t) 

These contributions are ignored since the factor  E(w)  is too small given  wo  ® ∞ given it varies as w-1  for large  w, i.e.

E (w ) =  4pe/ k2 e (k,w)   ò  dv f1  (k, v, t= 0)/  v x-  (w/ k)


The next segment of the deformed contour to consider goes from point E to ∞ and yields the integral:

   E(t) ~  ò¥ E  dw/ 2p  [exp (-iwt)] E (w)

which vanishes for wo  ®  ∞  given the integrand oscillates infinitely rapidly.   The response to any initial perturbation therefore consists of normal modes oscillating with normal mode frequencies given by:

1 + we2/ k2   ò  du  d u g(u)/ w/ k - u =0   

After some time we find the normal mode with the greatest imaginary part dominates.  Note here that a localized perturbation in a space plasma has a spectrum of wave numbers k, while the preceding equations - for simplicity - focused on a single k.  In the case of the spectrum of k the response will consist of a spectrum of normal modes at different k. If any one of these normal mode frequencies has a +ve imaginary part then the plasma will be unstable and the perturbation will grow with time.  

Derivation of the Plasma Dispersion Function:

This function often denoted Z(x) is a fundamental special function in plasma physics used to evaluate kinetic wave-particle interactions, wave propagation, and damping phenomena (such as Landau damping) in hot, collisionless plasmas. 

Consider the template integral:

ò ¥-¥  du [dfo(u) /du / (u -  w/ k)]


Given a Maxwellian in 1-d:

  f  o      = n (x)/Ö(p) vo  [exp(- u2 /vo)]

Where vo =   vthermal


Then applying the template integral:

dfo(u) /du  =   - 2n /Ö(p) vo3 [ò ¥-¥  du [dfo(u) /du / (u -  w/ k)]

Then:  I (w) = 

- 2n /Ö(p) vo3 [ò ¥-¥  du [u exp(u2 /vo2) /( u -  w/ k) 

= - 2n /Ö(p) vo3 ò du {u   -  w/ k) +w/ k)]exp (-u2/vo2)} /(u -  w/ k)  

= - 2n /Ö(p) vo3 ò ¥-¥  du exp (-u2/vo2) + ò  du   w/ k/(u -  w/ k)} (exp (-u2/vo2)

Finally:

ò ¥-¥   exp (-u2/vo2)/ [u/vo) - w/ k/vo )]  d(u/vo) 

Yields :    ò ¥-¥   dZ exp (-Z 2) / (z - Z )


The plasma dispersion function, tabulated by Fried and Conte (1961)

See:

  The Plasma Dispersion Function: The Hilbert Transform of the Gaussian


Wednesday, November 18, 2026

More On The Background To AI Math Training - And Answers To The AI Sample Problems

How did AI models reach the phase -  by October 2026 - of releasing 372 groups of results encompassing  roughly 4,000 math problems in total?  These results also including the models' "chains of thought".  Recall in last week's post I noted by mid-2023 Open AI's model had only scored a 23%  on the H.S. competition's hardest problems.

Well, by the end of 2024 Open AI's model hit 95% on that exam. Bigger strides were to follow. Once the AI models aced the American Invitational Mathematics Examination (AIME) and won gold medals at math Olympiads they graduated from high school math to open problems whose solutions had bedeviled mathematicians for decades.

Before looking at those, a bit more on the AIME.  This is a prestigious 15-question, 3-hour math competition organized by the Mathematical Association of America (MAA). It serves both as an elite high school math contest and a widely used benchmark for evaluating the mathematical reasoning of AI models. The test consists of 15 increasingly difficult problems covering algebra, geometry, number theory, and combinatorics. Because every answer is an exact integer between 000 and 999, this eliminates multiple-choice guessing while rewarding precise calculation. Because answers must be exact three-digit integers rather than multiple choice, AI models cannot rely on luck or elimination to score well.

Then there came the deluge of more recent (2026) problem -solving which had mathematicians' heads spinning. Among the most significant:

  • Navier–Stokes Existence and Smoothness Problem: In September 2026, an internal OpenAI system deployed thousands of AI agents to produce a proof showing that the dynamics of 3D Navier-Stokes fluid equations can develop a singularity in finite time, marking an approach to one of the seven Clay Mathematics Institute Millennium Prize Problems.
In my Sept. 25th post, I noted the statement of the American Mathematical Society concerning this claim and the consequences. First, the AMS statement:

"The news today of progress on resolving the Navier–Stokes problem, one of mathematics' great longstanding challenges concerning the equations that govern the flow of fluids, represents a milestone advance in human knowledge. This story began with Navier, Stokes, Leray, and Ladyzhenskaya and has culminated in the recent breakthroughs of Córdoba and Martínez-Zoroa, then — assisted by new technologies — Alpöge and Buckmaster, with the final steps taken by OpenAI mathematicians. The purpose of mathematics is human understanding, and this achievement, and the process that led to it, will bear fruit for a long time to come."

The statement by the AMS does not assert a solution has been found to the 3D Navier-Stokes equation, mainly because there is still an open debate. This is mainly because the Open A.I. "forced fluid scenario" relies on a contrived external force that does not occur in real world fluid dynamics. Removing that contrived force causes the mathematical singularity ('blow up') to disappear.  This is neat, but then little useful insight emerges into actual physical turbulence (or the unforced Navier-Stokes problem researchers really care about.)

Moving on to other AI advances:

  • Riemann Hypothesis & Prime Numbers: OpenAI released research advancing work on the Riemann hypothesis, ruling out a specific "seagull zero" rogue point for related functions and proving constraints on prime number distribution, with formal checks verified in the Lean proof assistant.
I will be doing a post on the Riemann hypothesis in the near future and AI's role.

  • 4D Yang–Mills Existence Problem: In October 2026, OpenAI released a massive 1,147-page AI-generated proof placing the 4D Yang-Mills quantum field theory on rigorous mathematical footing (though the withheld raw text has drawn calls for full open release).
Next year I plan to do a two-part examination of the 4D Yang-Mills Existence problem and more on the AI contribution.

  • Computer Science & Decades-Old Conjectures: AI systems disproved a long-standing computer science conjecture and delivered solutions or formal proofs for the Cycle Double Cover Theorem, the Unique Games Conjecture, and aspects of the Kakeya problem.

  • Multi-Agent Benchmarks: Collaborative AI harnesses like ProofCouncil (combining frontier models from OpenAI, Anthropic, and Google) have scaled up to solving multiple top-tier research and olympiad-level mathematical challenges.  


Back now to the answers to the sample problems from my Nov. 12 post:

Grade school soln.   Take temp. 20    Subtract 80   =  - 60
Then add  30 =  - 60  +  (30)=  - 30        (Ans.C )   

SAT level soln.: First convert 26 mins. to hrs.  26/60 = 13/30 hr.

Then average speed of horse =   11 mi/ (13/30) hr. =  11 mi/ 0.433 hr.
 = 25.4 mph

H.S. competition soln.

Each complete circuit (spin) = 3600  
 
She spins a total of 2,25o degrees. Then total no. of spins:      

=  22500  /3600  

= 6.25 or 6 and 1/4
 
Since she's initially facing N the extra quarter turn at the end puts her direction East. (E)

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Solving Trigonometric Equations (Part Two) - Using Trigonometric Identities

 In Part One, I showed basic trig equations not involving trigonometric identities.  In other words, these could be solved in a straightforward manner, i.e. factoring or using quadratic equations typical of intermediate algebra.  In this post I look at examples of trig equations that are not factorable as given, but can be rendered so by applying one or more trigonometric identities. A table of such identities is given below:




 In addition we can look at the solution of equations in the form:  

A sin q   + B cos q  = C

Which solution entails writing A and B individually in the forms:

A = r cos a     and B = r sin a    making the base equation:

r (cos a sin q +  sin a cos q)  = C 

 then making use of the fact that the expression in parentheses is an identity such that:

sin (q + a  ) = C/ r

Now, some example problems:

Example problem (1):

Solve the equation:

sin 2q +  sin q -  2sinq cos q = 0

The problem can be readily solved by checking the table of trig identities and locating:

  sin 2q = 2 sin q cos q 

Then on substituting into the original eqn.

sin 2q +  sin q -  sin 2q  = 0

sin q = 0

q = 0  (from table of trig functions and angle values)


Example problem (2)  

Solve the equation:

cos 2q -  2cos q  = 0

the identity to use here is:

cos 2q  =  2cos2 q - 1

On substituting into the original eqn.

2cos 2 q - 1 -  2cos q  = 0

Or: 2cos 2 q - 2cos q  - 1 = 0

This can be solved using the quadratic formula:


In standard algebraic form: 2 x2  - 2x  - 1 = 0   

a=2, b= -2, c=-1

Let cos q =   x  then:

cos q =  2 +  Ö(-2)  -  4(2)(-1)/  2(2)

 = 1 +  Ö3 / 2  =  1.366,  - 0.366

There can be no values of cosine greater than 1 so 1.366 is impossible. This leaves the angle  for which cos q =  - 0.366

From a  table for cosines the angle is found to be:

q =  68 o 32’

The 2nd and 3rd quadrant solutions satisfying 0  <  q   < 2p:

q =  111 o28',     248 o 32'


Example problem (3)

 Solve the Equation:

2 cos q - 5 +  2 sec q  = 0  

Use table of identities: sec q  = 1/cos q

rewrite eqn.

2 cos q - 5 +  2/ cos q  = 0  

Multiply each term by cos q:

2 cos2 q -  5 cos q + 2 = 0 

Factor the resulting quadratic:

(2 cos q - 1) ( cos q - 2) = 0

cos q =  ½,   cos q =  2

From table of angles and trig functions:

cos q =  2  is impossible (No values of cosine greater than 1 )

cos q =  ½    Þ    q =  p/ 3,   5p/ 3


Example problem (4)  

Solve the equation:

Ö3 sin q + cos q =  1

Solution:  We can use the form: A sin q   + B cos q  = C

Where: A = r cos a     and B = r sin a  )

A =  Ö3 ,   B  = 1   and  tan a = B/ A = 1/ Ö3 

 r  =  Ö(A2   +   B2 ) =  Ö4  =   2  

Then  a  = 30 o   or any other angle whose tangent = 1/ Ö3 

rationalized as  Ö3 / 3.  So long as:

(A2   +   B2 ) =   r2 (cos2a +  sin 2 a) =  r2

 The given equation  Ö3 sin q + cos q =  1 can then be written as:

sin (q +  30 o) =  ½

The desired q values are then:  

(q +  30 o) = 30 o and 150 o

from which  q  = 0 o and 120 o  are the non-negative solutions less than 360 o


Suggested Problems:

1) Use a trigonometric identity - or combination thereof - to show:

 r2 (cos2a +  sin 2 a) =  r2

2) Solve the equation:

 2cot 2 q - 13 cot q  + 6  = 0

Using trigonometric identities or otherwise.

3) Solve the equation:

tan 2q  - 1 = 5

4) Solve the equation:

Ö3 sin q - cos q =  1.2

5) Solve the equation:

  1 - sin 2 q =  tan 2q -  sin 2 q 

Using any trigonometric identity

6) Solve the equation:

 2 sin 2 q  -  cos 2q = 0

Using trigonometric identities