Caravan of Haitian migrants approaching U.S. border 3 yrs. ago
Angst is blowing up across immigrant districts in Blue states and it's because Trump the Top Thug has threatened ICE raids and mass deportations of as many as 20 million immigrants. But as with most planned power grabs, Dotard hasn't thought this one through. Here are five reasons the mass deportations will remain a brain fart nestled in Trump's amygdala.
1- Immigrants in the U.S. can't be illegally deported without court hearings.
Once they touch U.S. soil they are entitled to due process, in an immigration court where they have the chance to seek asylum or seek another avenue to remain in the country. The problem is our immigration courts are so backlogged (according to the WSJ, Jan. 2, p. A5) hearing are now being scheduled as far ahead as 2029. As noted by the WSJ piece ('Immigration Plan Faces Big Roadblocks):
"Outside experts estimate that Congress would have to hire at least 5,000 immigration court judges, given the system now has barely 500."
This will never happen barring a large infusion of cash. Maybe Trump can ask his Billionaire bud Musk for it.
2- There Aren't enough ICE Agents:
This was kind of a shocker given the level of bombast one has heard the past few weeks regarding Trump planning to "declare a state of emergency" on day one etc. But if he wants to confirm he's a total fool, let him go ahead and try it but minus the manpower to carry it out. As the WSJ piece notes again (ibid.):
"The U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement Agency currently has roughly 6,000 agents on staff and funding to jail about 40,000 immigrants at any given time. It doesn't have nearly the fleet of planes needed to deport millions of immigrants back to their home countries.".
The Reeps - we learn (ibid.) are hoping to use a budget process called reconciliation to get the needed ICE money. But it still would need final sign off by the House where Reeps have tenuous majority. Good luck getting it through. And btw you also may want to check the next item.
3. Immigrants can no longer be deported to one country:
In the past deportation was easy -peasy, ICE agents usually just sent them back to Mexico. No longer. As The Financial Times recently noted, the last few 'tidal waves' of migration have featured migrants from up to 65 nations - every place from Ecuador, to China, to Bangladesh, to Sudan and in between. As the WSJ piece notes:
"Over the past few years immigrants crossing into the U.S. illegally have come from record numbers of countries such as China, India, Mauritania and Uzbekistan. The U.S. today can't simply load all migrants onto a flight heading to the same place. It would now have to orchestrate a complex dance of flights, choosing where to send its limited number of planes and fighting with the governments about when - and whether- they'd accept these flights at all."
Is Trump ready to implement dozens of different jet flights daily over YEARS- at the cost of billi0ns- to deport those migrants back to all their respective homelands? I doubt it. Nor will they get that much funding even if they wanted to do it. (Apart from the logistical nightmares).
4. Blue States Will Not Just 'Roll Over' For Capt. Bonespurs
The Blue states (CA, NY, MD etc.) have large enclaves of immigrants but they will not sit quietly and just allow Trump Storm Troopers to barge in and drag them out. A number (e.g. Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson) have already said they would not be cooperating with federal immigration authorities. This is especially if that segment of valid immigrants - who deserve an immigration court hearing- have not been granted their court dates yet. (Which as I noted may not be until the year 2029 unless the currently backlogged courts are expanded. As the WSJ piece observes (ibid.):
"While it is still possible to arrest people living illegally in blue -led cities, it is far more challenging without local cooperation....Without local cooperation ICE would need to post officers on watch outside jails for hours or days to catch a release. Neighborhood raids are also possible but - unlike regular police officers- they do not have warrants to make an arrest."
Trump officials have publicly bruited pursuing criminal prosecutions of all the officials enforcing sanctuary policies. But good luck on that scheme if you've already skipped legitimate immigration court hearings.
Which brings us to:
5. Legal Challenges:
Many of the forcible changes and fantasies proposed by Trump and his incoming deputy (and Goebbels look-alike) Stephen Miller, can only be done through congress - or by constitutional amendment.
Good luck on either of those given Reeps simply lack the majorities in either Senate or House to get that done. Oh, let me also quickly add that Trump's fantasy of ending birthright citizenship (as the WSJ notes)- can't be done by congress or by any executive order.
In the end, it appears Dotard Trump will be more in the position of the dog that caught the car, than as the powerful autocrat he fancies himself and who runs the country by dictate.
But anyone with more than air between the ears would know he's blowing nothing but brain farts. This is given he also claimed yesterday he plans to change the name of the Gulf of Mexico to the "Gulf of America". Oh, and "annex" Canada as a 51st state. The two-legged cockroach troll also hasn't ruled out military force to take over the Panama Canal as well as Greenland. Is reducing inflation anywhere on his agenda - after making that promise to the gullible, low IQ "economic" voters? Not at all. Only grabbing headlines and media attention with the most outrageous brain caca the roach can muster.
See Also:
Mass Global Migration Will Never Be Stopped By Laws - Because It's Fueled By Overpopulation
And:
by Thom Hartmann | January 7, 2025 - 6:11am | permalink
“Beware that, when fighting monsters, you yourself do not become a monster... for when you gaze long into the abyss, the abyss gazes also into you.”
—Friedrich Nietzsche
To get the public to go along with the kind of radical social change that strips people of rights and privileges — and, eventually, their wealth — requires a shock to the political system which can then be exploited by a cynical political leader, his party, and their media allies.
In the second month of his reign, for example, Hitler had his Reichstag Fire, which pushed the German Parliament to pass “emergency” laws expanding his executive power and limiting the reach of parliament and the rights of average people. It ended the rights of assembly, freedom of speech and the press, protections against unlawful search and seizure, and gave him the power to designate persons and organizations as terrorists by decree.
Somewhat similarly, George W. Bush had 9/11 during his first year, which enabled him to push through the PATRIOT Act and other laws that expanded our government’s ability to surveil Americans, engage in warrantless wiretaps, access personal records, and monitor financial transactions.