Thursday, October 29, 2026

This Brewer Fan Could Have Told The Rays Their 12th Inning Game 4 Win Was A Fluke

 

Brewer catcher Contrera and MVP Trophy after Milwaukee Series win

             Brewers celebrate championship right after beating Rays last night
               Glum Tampa Bay Rays after losing 4-1 to Brewers last night


It was no surprise to this long time (57 yrs.) Brewers’ fan that the Tampa Bay Rays jumped for joy too soon following the shocking Brewers' 4-3, loss to the Rays at Tropicana Field on Tuesday night, Oct. 27. The Rays (and their fans) really needed to process that the 12th inning collapse was a fluke, set up by Brewers’ manager Pat Murphy  - over thinking his choice of relief pitcher for the Rays half of the 12th.

No kidding. True, this was a bloody hard loss, almost as bad as the game 7 Brewer loss  to the St. Louis Cardinals in the 1982 Series, after taking a 3-1 lead into the 6th inning. Without the relief power of Rollie Fingers – out from a pitching arm injury – the Brew Crew lost 6-3 to the %#$!*  Cards.  The pain stayed with Brewers’ fans for 44 years.

So yeah, we know how it is when a World Series championship is dangled in front of you, only to be snatched away. The sad and of this game truly was champagne showers fading into cold showers. But Rays’ fans needed to grasp why their Game 4 win was a fluke.

For one thing, the reliever – Shane Drohan- was a raw rookie. And obviously not the optimum choice to get the 3 outs to close the game. In fact I winced as the guy gave up 4 consecutive singles, to say he was not sharp is an understatement. Indeed, Drohan had pitched only once in the past month.

The guy to put in there was therefore ‘the Miz’  (Jacob Misiorowski )– to nail those last three outs with a Brewer lead. But Murphy told a Milwaukee reporter after the game:

“You can’t blow that type of situation on a one-run lead on the road. If we were in the 13th inning and had a three-run lead, it might be a little different.”

Are you f-ing kidding me? You blew the situation by opting to use a raw, rusty rook out of his depth! Then, before that move, using relief ace Trevor Megill for only one out to complete the eighth inning. He ought to have used him at least for another full inning before going to Aaron Ashby. 

With the Megill mess-up and Ashby’s speed below 95 mph, Miz was the obvious next choice using his 100+ mph heaters to shut the last 3 Rays down. But for some odd reason pitching his ace with a one-run lead in the 12th inning was not a risk Murphy was willing to take. So instead he opted for the risk of a rookie reliever in Drohan whose history of bad pitches were known. To wit, Drohan got to two strikes on each of the first three Rays hitters he faced, but then couldn’t generate the final 3rd strike swings and misses. Instead leaning heavily on his sinker, which opponents hit .364 and slugged .568 against. 

The whole sad ending was totally predictable, and using Miz would have been a 180 degree different outcome. I was sure of it.

But hey, Miz was left to finish the job in Game Five and he did, hurling 5 2/3 shutout innings. The Brew Crew offense also came through to support him with timely hits, staking him to a 2-0 lead early, then 4-0 three innings later.

The backstory of the lousing relief needs to be mentioned for the benefit of the Rays and their fans, namely that Tuesday night’s win was purely a delusion. Also Series’ history. 25 teams have taken a 3-0 lead in the World Series and 21 finished with a sweep. But the remaining 4 needed only an extra game to reach the championship – like the Brewers did last night.

Lastly, as a long time (72 year) Milwaukee baseball fan, as I’ve been waiting 69 years since the Milwaukee Braves beat the NY Yankees in the 1957 Series, 4 game to 3. Pitcher Lew Burdette beating the Yanks  3 times. See e.g.

1957 WS Gm7: Braves defeat Yankees to win 1957 WS | 10/10/1957 | MLB.com


 


No comments: