Thursday, May 29, 2025

Trump's "Golden Dome" Fantasy - Yet Another Colossal Waste Of Money That Rivals Reagan's Star Wars Boondoggle

 

 Trump's Golden Dome fantasy is $175 b boondoggle- Where Is DOGE?


It really seems, when it comes to the Trumpites, past is prologue. And by that I mean an ever metastasizing dark age, dark past, now overwhelming present culture and scientific  advances. As well as reason, end common sense.

The preference then is for regression not progress. We see it in the attacks on the universities, the most recent Harvard. As if the country can afford the wanton destruction of its brainpower – and letting it flee to China or the EU.

We also saw at the outset of Dotard’s reign, the first target of DOGE was US Aid, and for what? To save maybe $12 million. Meantime, the Trumpites are prepared to send the nation’s deficits soaring to over $36 trillion by passing a reckless tax cut that will only benefit the richest. Estimated 6 figure returns for the upper 0.5% and a couple hundred for the hoi polloi – most of whom voted for Trump hoping for better breaks.   But now they will likely get their couple hundred in tax cuts but lose their Medicaid, their 'Meals on Wheels', food stamps and more – to appease the oligarchs.

Adding wasteful insult to the existing financial injury of a looming trade war, idiotic tariffs, and soaring bond yields – we have the spectacle of $175 billion to build a “Golden Dome” missile defense system for the U.S.  But make no mistake that this is a Dotard pipe dream, a fantasy no different than Ronnie Raygun’s Star Wars (SDI or strategic defense initiative) malarkey.

Point of fact: Since April, The U.S. has been asking defense contractors for information on space-based interceptors to knock out incoming missile threats, as the Pentagon explores Trump's ill-advised Golden Dome incarnation.

But the idea of mounting rockets, or lasers, to satellites so they can shoot down enemy intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBMs) as they lift off is not new - it was part of a loopy, short-sighted initiative devised during the presidency of Reagan. It represents a huge and expensive technological leap from current capabilities. It is also a mindless boondoggle and waste, which will be no more effective than Ronnie’s Star Wars bollocks.

Nor any more effective than the THAAD missile shield that emerged under Bush Jr and Obama.  THAAD (Terminal High Altitude Defense)  -  had only been "successful" because of GPS finder beacons attached to the warheads of the dummy targets.  We've actually known about this tomfoolery or fakery the past 25 years or so.  Reuters was the only news agency that got wind of the initial 'Defense Week' story back then  and revealed the fix. The wire service quoted a Pentagon official who "conceded that real warheads in an attack would not carry such helpful beacons". Gee thanks much, Roscoe! I'm sure I'll sleep better at night now, supposing maybe you guys secretly planted beacons on the North Korean warheads.

As for the Dotard 'Golden Dome'  version of a missile shield, the so-called notice arrived compliments of the Missile Defense Agency and U.S. Space Force – both of which are holding a series of meetings to discuss space-based interceptors. It’s all a waste of time and brain power, friends.

In the notice, they supposedly asked companies to provide specific information on actual or conceptual "space-based interceptors" that would knock out ICBMs during the "boost phase" - the initial slow and predictable climb through the Earth's atmosphere. (Current defenses are only able to target enemy missiles as they travel through space.)

The Pentagon said it is also interested in concepts capable of "post-boost, early midcourse, or midcourse intercept that show a path to boost-phase intercept, including kinetic and non-kinetic effectors, sensors/seekers, and fire control solutions."

Give me a break.  Didn’t these geniuses figure out the inherent chuckle factor when Bush Junior tried to advance them?

Guess not.

According to Tom Karako, a weapons and security expert at the Center for Strategic and International Studies:

This notification would seem to confirm the near likelihood that both space sensors and space-based interceptors will be a key component of Golden Dome's forthcoming architectural plans, which will probably emerge in the coming weeks," 

The MDA has established multiple delivery timelines for Golden Dome, with the earliest capabilities expected by December 31, 2026, and additional capabilities phased through 2030 and beyond.

The “industry engagement” was supposedly held in Alabama over multiple days from April 30 to May 2. It emerged amid growing hysteria about advanced missile threats from Russia and China, as well as regional powers such as North Korea and Iran. Hypersonic weapons, which can maneuver at speeds exceeding Mach 5, pose particular challenges to existing ground- and sea-based interceptor systems that target enemy missiles during the portion of their flight path when they have the greatest maneuverability and can most effectively evade missile defenses.

In truth, the Space Horizons Research Task Force already knows all it needs to, i.e. that what's being proposed is merely a resurrection of the old Strategic Defense Initiative (SDI), which was never proven workable or even remotely feasible.  It depended upon incorporating space-based interceptors as well as powerful lasers mounted on satellites to take down Soviet ICBMs.   

The  most devastating exposure of this missile defense con (which likewise applies to the ‘Golden Dome’ hooey) appeared in the May, 1987 issue of Physics Today and was entitled "APS Directed Energy Weapons Study (Executive Summary)".   Versions of it  subsequently appeared in other journals, including the Reviews Of Modern Physics, e.g.

https://journals.aps.org/rmp/abstract/10.1103/RevModPhys.59.S1


The study basically took apart the 'Star Wars' rubbish piece by piece  with no fewer than 26 major  deficiencies identified on everything from the weaknesses of the proposed lasers to shoot down the incoming missiles (too weak by several orders of magnitude) to the problem of identifying the targets "at sub-micro-radian resolution"  in the boost phase  to "lack of precision tracking via active sensor systems" and the ease with which any missile  interceptor design can easily be thwarted, say by use of dispersal of million of reflecting, metallic decoys. 

Even two years earlier, in an article  appearing in the June, 1985 issue of Physics Today (p. 34, 'The Strategic Defense Initiative Perception Vs, Reality'), the SDI was dismissed as a "political PR promotion scheme".  In other words, it was created purely to pump up defense budgets and enrich all those contractors who'd be manufacturing the components of this farce. As the author (Wolfgang Panofsky) pointed out:

"What is frightening at this time is the blatant salesmanship, which does not focus on SDI';s military merits but which appeals to economic self interest."

Adding:

"There exists at this time no technical basis that justifies expanding research and technology programs in ballistic missile defense beyond a program of limited experimentation ...and studies of an objective rather than promotional manner."

Nor is there any basis now for expanding an analogous research and technology program. There is absolutely NO assurance, zero,  that anything different will be achieved with this Golden Dome codswallop.  But the Trumpers’ brainiacs are prepared to piss away over $175b to try to prove a bullet can still hit a bullet – even one moving at 17,000 mph.

 See Also:

Trump: Golden Dome will cost around $175B, be 'fully operational' in three years | DefenseScoop

And:

Brane Space: A New "Space Force"? One Of The Dumbest Ideas Since Reagan's "Star Wars" - But NOT Dotard's


No comments: